The Paul VI High School community is grappling with immense grief after the sudden and tragic loss of one of its brightest stars, 17-year-old senior Carter Cunniff. On the morning of April 15, 2025, Carter’s life was cut short in a devastating car accident that has left not only his family but also his friends, coaches, and fellow students in shock. His passing has left a profound void in the halls of Paul VI and in the hearts of all who had the privilege of knowing him. This is a loss that the community of Haddonfield, New Jersey, will mourn deeply, as Carter’s life was one marked by positivity, leadership, and a dedication to everything he did.
Carter’s tragic accident occurred in the early hours of April 15, around 12:11 a.m., while he was driving his Toyota Camry southbound on State Route 55. For reasons that are still under investigation, his vehicle veered off the roadway, striking both a concrete overpass support and a tree. New Jersey State Police responded quickly, but Carter had already succumbed to the injuries sustained in the crash. The tragic and unexpected nature of his passing has left the community grappling with an overwhelming sense of loss and disbelief.
To those who knew him, Carter was more than just a student at Paul VI High School; he was a beacon of light and positivity, a young man who made a lasting impact on every person he met. He was not only known for his achievements on the field but also for his character off the field. Whether on the volleyball court, the soccer field, or in the classroom, Carter approached life with a determination that was contagious and inspiring. His commitment to excellence, leadership, and compassion set him apart and made him a role model for many of his peers.
Carter was a standout athlete, excelling in both volleyball and soccer. As a libero on the Paul VI High School Boys Volleyball Team, Carter became known for his sharp instincts and relentless defensive play. Although he played only two matches during the 2024-2025 season, his impact was undeniable. He recorded an impressive 22 digs, averaging 11 per match, along with one kill and four service aces. His standout performance came during a 2-0 sweep over Camden Eastside, where he recorded nine digs and three aces, leading his team with both his performance and his spirit. His dedication and passion for volleyball inspired not only his teammates but also his coaches, who admired his work ethic and leadership.
In addition to volleyball, Carter was also a dedicated member of the Paul VI Boys Soccer Team. He spent years growing as a player, earning the respect of his teammates and coaches alike. On the field, Carter played with intensity and joy, always putting the team above himself. His passion for the game and his selfless approach to being part of the team made him a beloved figure in the locker room. His teammates will remember him not only for his athleticism but also for his ability to bring positivity and energy to the team, even during the toughest of times.
Beyond his athletic accomplishments, Carter was known for his infectious smile, easygoing spirit, and his remarkable ability to connect with others. His friends recall his sense of humor, his loyalty, and his ability to make everyone feel valued and seen. Carter was the kind of person who would drop everything to support a friend in need, and his friendships were built on trust, respect, and mutual admiration. His classmates and teachers often described him as a dedicated student who approached learning with curiosity, enthusiasm, and a genuine desire to better himself. Carter’s positive influence and willingness to help others made him a truly remarkable young man, and his passing has left an irreplaceable void in the lives of those who knew him.
In the wake of his tragic death, Paul VI High School released a heartfelt statement honoring Carter’s memory. The school community expressed their deep sadness and admiration for the young man who had exemplified the very best of what their school stood for: faith, excellence, leadership, and compassion. The statement read: “Carter Cunniff exemplified the very best of our school community—faith, excellence, leadership, and compassion. His loss is deeply felt by students, faculty, coaches, and families. We are united in grief and prayer, and we extend our deepest sympathy to Carter’s family and loved ones during this incredibly difficult time.”
Carter’s family, who are devastated by this loss, are finding comfort in the many memories they shared with him. He is survived by his parents, Mike Cunniff and Diane Zalewski Cunniff, whose hearts are broken by the loss of their beloved son. Mike, a respected logistics director at Holt Logistics and a graduate of Pennsylvania State University, was always deeply involved in his sons’ lives, supporting them in every endeavor. Diane, while less present on social media, has been a steadfast and loving presence in Carter’s life. The family is overwhelmed with grief but is also grateful for the outpouring of love and support from the community.
To honor Carter’s life and legacy, plans are underway for a memorial to be held at Paul VI High School. This memorial service will provide students, families, and staff the opportunity to gather, reflect, and celebrate Carter’s life. Details about the memorial service will be shared with the school community in the coming days. The service will be a time for everyone who knew Carter to come together, share stories, and offer comfort to one another during this difficult time. It will also serve as a reminder of the love, joy, and positivity that Carter brought to the lives of all those around him.
In addition to the memorial service, the community has come together to support Carter’s family through this devastating loss. A GoFundMe campaign has been launched to assist the family with funeral arrangements and to offer financial support during this difficult time. The family is deeply appreciative of the kindness and generosity shown to them by the community, and they are grateful for the outpouring of love they have received.
Carter’s life, though tragically short, was one filled with love, joy, and purpose. His legacy will continue to inspire his family, friends, and the entire Paul VI High School community. Carter’s memory will live on in the hearts of all who had the privilege of knowing him, and his spirit will continue to guide and inspire those who were touched by his kindness, leadership, and determination.
Rest in peace, Carter. Your kindness, generosity, and love for life will never be forgotten. Your legacy lives on in the hearts of all who knew you, and your spirit will continue to inspire us all. You will be deeply missed, but your memory will remain with us forever.
The post Carter Cunniff Obituary, Death NJ: Paul VI High School Mourns the Loss of a Beloved Student, Athlete, and Friend first appeared on Trusted and Verified USA News.
