Wikipedia is now caught in the middle of a political battle between Democrats and Republicans after it allowed a single user, with a less than stellar record on the site edit out vice presidential candidate J.D. Vance’s military awards and medals earned during his combat correspondent deployment to Iraq.
J.D. Vance, the U.S. Senator from Ohio and author of the bestselling memoir Hillbilly Elegy, recently found himself at the center of a Wikipedia controversy when several of his military decorations were removed from his page.
The change, which occurred between July 28th and July 30th, 2024, stripped references to three of his military awards: the Global War on Terrorism Service Medal, the Iraq Campaign Medal, and the Navy and Marine Corps Sea Service Deployment Ribbon.
The Original Military Record
On July 28th, Vance’s Wikipedia page listed his military service record as follows:
- Allegiance: United States
- Branch/Service: United States Marine Corps
- Years of Service: 2003–2007
- Rank: Corporal
- Unit: 2nd Marine Aircraft Wing
- Battles/Wars: Iraq War
- Awards:
- Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal
- Marine Corps Good Conduct Medal
- Global War on Terrorism Service Medal
- Iraq Campaign Medal
- Navy and Marine Corps Sea Service Deployment Ribbon
This record reflected his four-year service in the Marine Corps, during which he was deployed to Iraq as part of the 2nd Marine Aircraft Wing. The awards listed were standard recognitions for service members who participated in the Iraq War and other related operations during that period.
The Revision and Its Impact
By July 30th, the Wikipedia page was updated, significantly altering the section on his military decorations. The revised entry retained only the Navy and Marine Corps Achievement Medal and the Marine Corps Good Conduct Medal. The edit was made by a user named “Cortador,” who justified the removal by stating that the article’s body did not confirm the existence of the removed medals and that reliable sources were needed to verify them.
Wikipedia User “Cortador” and Previous Controversies
The user “Cortador” is no stranger to Wikipedia edits that have sparked controversy. The account has previously been blocked by Wikipedia administrators for editing pages related to high-profile figures such as Boris Johnson, the former UK Prime Minister, and Ginni Thomas, the wife of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas. In both cases, the edits led to accusations of bias and led to temporary suspensions of the user.
Reactions and Implications
The deletion of Vance’s medals from his Wikipedia page has raised questions about the accuracy and integrity of user-generated content on the platform. Supporters of Vance have expressed outrage, suggesting that the edits were politically motivated. Critics argue that Wikipedia’s rules on sourcing and verification, which led to the removal, are necessary to maintain the credibility of the site, even if they result in the temporary deletion of accurate information.
Wikipedia has long been a battleground for partisan edits, where users with differing political agendas attempt to shape the public perception of figures like Vance. The incident underscores the importance of vigilant moderation on platforms that serve as primary information sources for millions of users worldwide.
