A recent arrest in Belmar, New Jersey, has ignited a public debate over the state’s beach badge system, leading to a petition calling for the elimination of beach access fees. The incident, which occurred on August 20, 2024, involved a surfer who was taken into custody for allegedly failing to display a beach badge while exiting the water.
The arrest, captured on video and widely shared on social media, has raised concerns about the enforcement of beach access regulations. Just days after the surfer’s arrest, on August 24, another individual was removed from Belmar Beach for sitting at the high tide line without a beach badge during a peaceful protest.
These incidents have fueled criticism of New Jersey’s long-standing beach badge requirement, which mandates that visitors pay for access to most of the state’s beaches. In response, attorney Andrew L. Chambarry has launched a petition calling for the repeal of the New Jersey Beach Fee Statute and the elimination of beach badges statewide.
Legal Background and Public Trust Concerns
The practice of charging for beach access in New Jersey dates back to the 1920s, with towns using the revenue to fund beach maintenance, safety measures, and public services. Despite legal challenges, the New Jersey Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of these fees, which have become a fixture in nearly all coastal communities.
However, critics argue that the fees create an economic barrier that unfairly restricts access to public resources. They point to the Public Trust Doctrine, which holds that natural resources, such as beaches, should be freely accessible to all. The New Jersey Administrative Code, specifically N.J.A.C. 7:7, supports this principle by stating that no fees should be charged solely for access to tidal waterways and their shores.
Petition Calls for Action
Chambarry’s petition argues that the enforcement of beach badge requirements, as seen in the recent incidents in Belmar, represents an overreach of local authority. The petition highlights concerns that the current system places an unreasonable financial burden on the public and criminalizes those who fail to comply.
The petition also raises questions about the proper use of beach fee revenue. Under the New Jersey Beach Fee Statute, municipalities are required to use these funds exclusively for beachfront-related expenses. However, there have been allegations of funds being diverted to non-beachfront purposes, further eroding public trust.
In light of these issues, the petition calls for the New Jersey Legislature and the Governor to repeal the Beach Fee Statute and find more equitable ways to fund beach maintenance and safety. The petition has gained traction, reflecting a growing movement to ensure that New Jersey’s beaches remain accessible to everyone, regardless of financial means.
Ongoing Debate
The debate over beach badges in New Jersey is far from settled. Proponents of the current system argue that the fees are necessary to maintain the high quality of the state’s beaches, which attract millions of visitors each year. However, the recent incidents in Belmar have brought renewed attention to the question of whether these fees are fair and whether their enforcement is justified.
As the petition continues to gather support, it remains to be seen how state and local officials will respond. What is clear is that the issue of beach access in New Jersey has struck a chord with many residents and visitors, who are calling for change to ensure that the state’s natural resources are available to all.
